What Should You Do If a Filling Falls Out?

If a filling falls out, keep the piece if you find it, rinse your mouth with warm water, and call your dentist to book a visit within the next few days. It’s a common problem and usually not an emergency, but the exposed tooth is weaker and more prone to decay, and if you have strong pain or swelling you should see an emergency dentist the same day.

Fillings don’t last forever. Most fall out because the tooth around them has changed, not because the filling material suddenly failed.

When you call, a good dental office will ask a few quick questions: does it hurt, is the tooth sharp, and can you bite on it? That tells them how fast you need to come in.

Sometimes there’s decay under the old filling that has reached the nerve. In that case, root canal treatment can save the tooth.

For bigger gaps, restorative dentistry options like onlays and crowns give the tooth more support. And if you’re new to the area, our dental clinic in Richmond Hill can usually fit lost-filling repairs in quickly.

Is a lost filling a dental emergency?

Quick answer Usually not. A lost filling with no pain or mild sensitivity can wait a few days. Severe pain, swelling, fever, or a broken tooth with sharp edges cutting your tongue or cheek needs same-day care.

Here’s a simple way to judge it.

Your situationHow soon to see a dentist
No pain, small holeWithin a week
Sensitivity to cold or sweetsWithin 2 to 3 days
Sharp edge cutting your cheek or tongueWithin 1 to 2 days
Constant throbbing painSame day
Swelling in the gum or faceSame day
Fever or swelling that’s spreadingSame day, or the ER if you feel very unwell

Why do fillings fall out?

New decay around the filling

This is the most common reason. Bacteria get into the tiny gap where the filling meets the tooth. Decay eats the tooth structure under the edge, and eventually the filling has nothing to hold on to.

The filling was old

Every material wears. Silver (amalgam) fillings often last 10 to 15 years or more. Tooth-coloured composite fillings usually last somewhere around 5 to 10 years, depending on size and bite.

Chewing hard or sticky foods

Ice, hard candy, popcorn kernels, nuts and caramel can crack or pull a filling loose, especially an older one.

Grinding and clenching

Night grinding puts heavy, repeated force on fillings. Over time, it can crack them or the tooth around them.

A large filling in a weak tooth

When a filling replaces most of the tooth, the remaining walls are thin. Those walls can break off, taking the filling with them. Teeth like this often need an onlay or crown instead.

An injury

A fall, sports hit or biting something unexpectedly hard can knock a filling out.

What to do right after your filling falls out

Follow these steps in order.

  1. Take it out of your mouth. Don’t swallow it on purpose. If you accidentally swallowed it, don’t panic. It will almost always pass on its own.
  2. Keep the filling or piece. Put it in a small bag or container. It usually can’t be glued back, but it helps your dentist see what happened.
  3. Rinse with warm salt water. Half a teaspoon of salt in a cup of warm water. This cleans the area and soothes the gum.
  4. Check the tooth. Look in a mirror. Note any sharp edges, dark spots or broken pieces.
  5. Call your dentist. Explain whether you have pain, swelling or sharp edges.
  6. Protect the hole until your visit. A temporary filling kit from the pharmacy or a small piece of sugar-free gum can cover the spot for a day or 2.
  7. Manage discomfort. Use over-the-counter pain relief as directed on the label, and ask a pharmacist if you’re unsure what’s safe for you.
  8. Chew on the other side. Avoid very hot, cold, sweet, hard or sticky foods.

What not to do

  • Don’t try to glue the filling back with household or super glue. These are toxic and can damage the tooth.
  • Don’t poke at the hole with your tongue, toothpicks or fingers.
  • Don’t put aspirin directly on the gum. It burns the tissue.
  • Don’t ignore it because it doesn’t hurt. Painless holes still collect bacteria.
  • Don’t wait months. A small repair can turn into a root canal or extraction.

How will your dentist fix it?

The fix depends on how much healthy tooth is left and whether the nerve is involved.

TreatmentWhen it’s usedWhat it involves
New fillingSmall to medium hole, healthy nerveRemove decay, place composite in 1 visit
Inlay or onlayLarger hole, strong outer wallsCustom piece made to fit and bonded in place
CrownLarge hole, thin or cracked wallsCovers the whole tooth for strength
Root canal and crownDecay or crack reached the nerveClean and seal the inside, then protect with a crown
Extraction and replacementTooth can’t be savedRemove the tooth, then consider an implant or bridge

Your dentist will usually take an X-ray to check for decay under where the filling was and how close it is to the nerve.

Myths about dental pain and fillings

“Getting a filling always hurts.” Modern numbing gels and local anesthetic make most fillings comfortable. You’ll feel pressure and vibration, not sharp pain.

“If the tooth doesn’t hurt, it doesn’t need fixing.” Many cavities and lost fillings are painless until decay gets close to the nerve.

“I’m too nervous, so I’ll leave it.” Dental anxiety is very common. Tell the team you’re nervous. They can explain every step, give you breaks and agree on a hand signal so you’re in control.

“A lost filling means my dentist did a bad job.” Most fillings that fail have simply reached the end of their life or were undermined by new decay or grinding.

How to keep fillings from falling out

  • Brush twice a day with fluoride toothpaste and clean between your teeth every day.
  • Cut back on sugary drinks and frequent snacking.
  • Don’t chew ice, pens or hard candy.
  • Wear a night guard if you grind or clench.
  • Use a mouthguard for contact sports.
  • Get regular checkups so worn or leaking fillings get replaced before they fall out.

Real situations we see often

The popcorn kernel. A 38-year-old bit down on a hard kernel during a movie and felt something crunch. A piece of an old composite filling came out. No pain, just a rough edge. A new filling the following week fixed it in 1 short visit.

The ignored hole. A 50-year-old lost a filling and waited 8 months because it didn’t hurt. When pain finally started at night, decay had reached the nerve. The tooth needed a root canal and a crown instead of a simple filling.

The grinder. A 29-year-old kept cracking fillings on the same side. The real issue was night grinding. A new filling, an onlay on the weakest tooth and a night guard stopped the cycle.

Safety note: Get care the same day if you have swelling, fever, a bad taste with pus, or pain that over-the-counter medicine doesn’t control. A spreading dental infection can become serious. Children who lose a filling should be seen promptly, because baby teeth decay quickly. This article is general information and doesn’t replace an exam by a licensed dental professional.

What can you eat while you wait for your appointment?

Stick to soft, lukewarm foods and chew on the opposite side. Good choices include:

  • Yogurt, eggs and oatmeal
  • Soup that has cooled down a bit
  • Pasta, rice and soft cooked vegetables
  • Fish, tofu and shredded chicken
  • Bananas and smoothies (skip ice and added sugar)

Avoid nuts, chips, hard bread crusts, sticky candy, gum (unless sugar-free and on the other side), and very hot or icy drinks. Sugary foods feed the bacteria in the open hole, so rinse with water after eating.

Which filling material is right for the repair?

MaterialLooks likeTypical lifespanGood for
Composite resinTooth-colouredAbout 5 to 10 yearsSmall to medium fillings, front and back teeth
Amalgam (silver)Silver-greyOften 10 to 15 years or moreLarge back-tooth fillings, rarely placed new today
Glass ionomerTooth-coloured, less shinyShorterBaby teeth, root surfaces, temporary repairs
Ceramic inlay or onlayTooth-colouredOften 10 years or moreLarge repairs that need strength

Your dentist will suggest a material based on the size of the hole, where the tooth is and how hard you bite.

What happens at the repair visit?

Most lost-filling visits are short. You’ll have a quick exam and usually an X-ray. The dentist numbs the tooth, removes any decay and old material, cleans the area and places the new filling or takes a scan for an onlay or crown.

If you’re nervous, say so at the start. You can ask for numbing gel before the injection, headphones, breaks or a step-by-step explanation. Afterward, the tooth may feel a little tender for a day or 2, which is normal.

Getting a lost filling fixed in Richmond Hill

Look for a clinic that can see you quickly and explains your options in plain language. Every dentist you see should be registered with the Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario (RCDSO).

Hummingbird Dental is one of the most trusted dental clinics in Richmond Hill, and it won the Top Choice Award for Richmond Hill Dentist in 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025. Patients often call it the top dentist in Richmond Hill for fast, gentle repairs, and it’s a reliable emergency dental clinic in Richmond Hill with same-day emergency appointments when you need them.

New patients and CDCP (Canadian Dental Care Plan) patients are welcome. The team speaks English, Persian, Russian, Portuguese, Hindi and Urdu, so you can explain your symptoms in the language you’re most comfortable with.

The clinic is open 6 days a week, including Saturdays, with extended weekday evening hours. Find Hummingbird Dental at 10376 Yonge St #202, Richmond Hill, ON L4C 3B8. Call +1 647-370-2024 or email info@hummingbirddental.ca.

Frequently asked questions

Can I wait a week to fix a lost filling?

If there’s no pain, no swelling and no sharp edges, waiting a few days to a week is usually okay. Keep the area clean and chew on the other side. Longer delays raise the risk of decay and breakage.

What if I swallowed my filling?

Small pieces of filling usually pass through the digestive system without harm. If you choke, cough persistently or have trouble breathing, get medical help right away.

Can a dentist put my old filling back in?

Usually not. The old filling rarely fits perfectly again and there may be decay underneath. Your dentist will clean the area and place a new restoration.

Is it normal for a tooth to be sensitive after losing a filling?

Yes. The inner layer of the tooth, called dentin, is exposed and reacts to cold, heat and sweets. Sensitivity that turns into constant throbbing needs prompt attention.

How long does a temporary filling from the pharmacy last?

Pharmacy kits are meant for a day or 2, sometimes up to a week. They wear away with chewing and don’t protect against decay like a proper filling.

Conclusion

A lost filling is common and usually not an emergency, but the tooth is now open to decay and breakage.

Rinse, protect the area, avoid chewing on that side and book a visit within a few days, or the same day if there’s pain or swelling.

Fast treatment often means a simple new filling instead of a root canal or crown later.